"Our Best Policy Is Service"

Insure your
needs today!

Get a Quote Auto

Get a Quote Home

Get a Quote Business

Get a Quote Commercial Auto

Get a Quote Toy Vehicle

Get a Quote Employee Benefits

We have you covered...

Errors & Omissions General Liability Contractors Flood Motorcycle Bonds

Make a payment File a claim Get a quote

QUALITY INSURANCE SERVICES IN KENTUCKY AND SURROUNDING STATES SINCE 1974

Reynolds Insurance

Reynolds Insurance Agency, Inc. has been providing clients in Kentucky and surrounding states with knowledge and expertise since our opening in 1974. Founded by Paul Reynolds and operated by daughter Carolyn Reynolds, our agency treats clients like family. We specialize in providing insurance policies for the construction business, and we carry a range of other products as well. Our team is comprised of licensed insurance professionals with the experience to advise our clients on the best coverages to meet their needs.

Featured Carriers

How Can I Save More Money On Insurance?

We are here for you

Get started with a quote

Meet our staff

Beverly Harkleroad

Administrative Assistant

Carolyn A. Reynolds

President, CEO

Haley Bogie

Financial Specialist

Mackenzie Simpson

CSR

Monica C. Bucher

Agency Manager

What clients say

Friendly Staff.

-Olevia “Jane” Hembree

Lady was extremely nice and helpful. Although they weren't able to help us she called back promptly with advice.

-Tina Lambdin (T)

Your insurance is only as good as your agent, and I highly recommend this one.

-Nickie Guinn

Very helpful people

-Shawndra Gadd

My wife and I highly recommend Paul Reynolds insurance . They go out of their way to get you the best quotes on auto insurance . The office manager Sadie is courteous and extremely helpful every time we need a document . She even helps my wife fax documents for...

-Mike Barnett

Great customer service. We had very specific business needs and Reynolds Insurance exceeded our expectations. They have two offices. One in Berea and one in Richmond. Both are easy to get to and both have good parking. The Berea office is right on Chestnut St.

-Chad Hembree

Our latest articles

February 1, 2023

Welcome to Our New Website

Our dedicated staff of insurance professionals are here to assist you in securing a life insurance policy to protect you […]

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.